An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source software by daliah saper saper law offices, llc. While being the most widely used of the open source licenses, the viral nature of the gpl license can prove problematic for some commercial developers. Common open source software legal issues are explained below. License4j is a total solution for software product licensing. There are open source licenses that would require that software to. While these licenses can be individually tailored to each project, the most common licenses.
The panel will provide best practices for ensuring compliance, minimizing infringement and monitoring. If you receive software under an open source license, you can always use that software for commercial purposes, but that doesnt always mean you can place further restrictions on people who receive the software from you. Opensource licenses allow for distribution of freely collaborated software. Use the license preferred by the community youre contributing to or depending on. This table lists for each license what organizations from the foss community have approved it be it as a free software or as an open source license, how those organizations categorize it, and the license compatibility between them for a combined or mixed derivative work. Issues in using opensource software there are three major issues in using or reusing opensource software.
An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source software by daliah saper saper law offices, llc 505 n. I have no idea what i am doing with open source licensing. Licence server is designed to licence your own terminal application. Delving into the world of open source license comparison is not for the faint of heart.
You may create and distribute a larger work under terms of your choice, provided that you also comply with the requirements of this license for. Organizations usually approve specific versions of software licenses. An opensource license allows for a software product to be shared in certain ways, or for some types of collaborative research or development. Open source licenses are licenses that comply with the open source definition in brief, they allow software to be freely used, modified, and shared. Software can be dynamically linked to other lgpl licensed libraries without having to release your source code under lgpl. The best place to discuss an issue about an open source license, or about a potential. Open source licensing risks and requirements cle webinar. A permissive software license, sometimes also called bsdlike or bsdstyle license, is a free software license with minimal requirements about how the software can be redistributed.
They want others to be able to build on and share their code. You can change the source code or even change its mode of operation. Please see the open source definition, specifically point 6. Many developers and designers want to release their work into the world as opensource projects. This is also known as the duallicense strategy of commercial open source. Frequently answered questions open source initiative.
The comparison only covers software licenses with a linked article for details, approved by at least one expert group at the fsf, the osi, the debian project or the fedora project. The eclipse public license epl is an open source software license used by eclipse foundation for its software. But opposing that growth in complexity is an understandable desire to release open source software under licenses that are widelyrecognized andor easy to comprehend in other. In some cases, especially when the software has multiple origins, all the accompanied. This projector product includes the open source software programs which apply the gnu lesser general public license version 2 or later version lgpl programs. Legal issues arising from the use of free and open source software in. Open source and thirdparty software license agreement. Much of the software we use daily is opensourcefrom operating systems and servers to the apps we use to ply our trades.
Outlines common open source license obligations when you download an open source package and use it inside your software. An opensource license is a type of license for computer software and other products that allows the source code, blueprint or design to be used, modified andor shared under defined terms and conditions. With more than 200 different open source licenses out there, each with its own terms and conditions, some copyleft viral, some permissive, some permissive with strings, and others with no open source license at all for which default laws apply, its tough to. Heres a guide to s, choosing a license, trademark registration, and patents. Care must be taken both when using oss, when distributing. Not all open source software is distributed under the same type of licensing agreement. Legal repercussions of open source software licensing. Weve seen above that if you exercise a little judgment in picking through your alternatives, you will generally find.
Source auditor license issues in embedding open source inside commercial software. Software licenses in plain english lookup popular software licenses summarized ataglance. The section choosing a license at the civic commons wiki may be useful, and you can learn more about open source licenses from, section 3. Open source software license gnu gpl this projector product includes the open source software programs which apply the gnu general public license version 2 june 1991 gpl programs. Much widelyused code is released under copyleft licenses. Comparison of free and opensource software licenses.
Seeking saas lawyer, software licensing attorney in columbus, ohio. This license is generally used for software libraries with exception of programs such as mozilla and open office. In general, opensource licensing allows the source code of a project to be open or transparent, utilized by third parties, or changed or manipulated by members of a developer community. No significant legal difference with free software. Open source trends license obligations, open source license obligations comments off on common open source license obligations since there are several hundred thousand free, widely used, and well maintained open source packages on the internet, it makes perfect sense to leverage open source whenever possible. We provide the source code of the lgpl programs until five 5 years after the discontinuation of same model of this projector product. Open source software has become a significant component of all software development activities, intentionally and sometimes unintentionally, thanks to the abundance of available code, its apparent free cost, and high degree of stability and security. What are the liability issues involved with using free and open source software foss. With open source licenses explained here, it should help you choose the right open source license for your project. Compliance with these license terms is key to avoiding problems with using oss. Mit license expat 826208 code license managed by kevin. An open source license protects contributors and users. The open source initiative, an organization founded in 1998 to promote open source software and normalize the use of the term, has approved more than 80 open source licenses.
This post takes a look at the legal issues raised by both cases and what they mean for foss producers and users. Today, the gpl license that stallman pioneered is in its third version and is only one of several dozen types of open source licenses. This product includes software licensed under the gnu general public license andor the gnu lesser general public license and other open source licenses such software, the software. Jul 29, 2015 an introduction to opensource licenses. Free and open source software licensing open source. Shared source, eventual source, and other licensing models. If some evil developer want to steal my code and use it in a closedsource software, how could i be aware of it, and how could i prove it since i dont have access to his source code. So a hacker comes along and says, oh, i see that hp is incorporating a line of. Open source vs licensed software software advisory service.
Only software licensed under an osiapproved open source license should be labeled open source software. This projector product includes the open source software programs which apply the gnu general public license version 2 or later version gpl programs. Licenses that are commonly associated with projects that contain publicly available code. A short guide to open source licenses smashing magazine. But while open source appears to be cost free, it is not without obligations, as it comes laden with licensing and responsibilities. There are open source licenses that would require that software to be open source as well though. You can integrate these codes into your client program by a few simple changes in a code. Oss watch provides unbiased advice and guidance on the use, development, and licensing of free software, open source software, and open source hardware. The internationally recognized open source definition provides ten criteria that must be met for any software license, and the software distributed under that license, to be labeled open source software. So, youre working on that cool new project for a while and youre ready now to make the critical move from closed source to open source. In conjunction with oss growth, intellectual property issues and licensing issues still remain. Although open source licensing s popularity has skyrocketed in the past two decades, in truth, open source was the original model for software licensing, with proprietary licensing coming later. This book also looks at issues affecting all of these licenses, includ ing the.
This work is licensed under a creative commons attributionsharealike 3. May 11, 2018 license4j is a total solution for software product licensing. The bsd license is popular because of the flexibility it allows its licensees. Which of the following best describes your situation. License compliance when you use open source components, you sign implicit legal contracts. The gnu general public licence gpl version 3 includes the restriction that any copies of the. We help address key licensing and development issues such as opensource. In general, open source licensing allows the source code of a project to be open or transparent, utilized by third parties, or changed or manipulated by members of a developer community. The license must not restrict other software, thus permitting the distribution of open. Open source open source initiative osi is a nonprofit organisation that certifies oss licences. It provides java libraries and gui tools for generation and validation of license files and license keys. In fact, the two models for software licensing open source and proprietary trace their origins from a common source. The opensource community is vibrant because of this.
Licensing limitations, conditions, and permissions oh my. Weve seen above that if you exercise a little judgment in picking through your alternatives, you will generally find one or more of quite respectable quality. Open source development an introduction to ownership and. Often, theres no user guides or manuals as they are not a legal requirement and when they are written, they tend to be written strictly for other. Understanding open source and free software licensing bridges the gap between the open source vision and the practical implications of its legal underpinnings. Identifying open source licenses, and understanding licensing compatibility and compliance, is an important part of any development project. This cle webinar will prepare counsel for companies using open source software to understand and address the legal risks of open source licensing. Theres also a section on software licenses in my r package primer.
There are three major issues in using or reusing open source software. Where can i discuss an issue about an open source license. An open source license allows for a software product to be shared in certain ways, or for some types of collaborative research or development. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source. Open source software has captured public attention during the past few years for its distinctive approach to software licensing and communitybased programming, as well as the growing market share of programs developed under the open source model. Open source vs licensed software when choosing software solutions, youll find yourself facing a rather intimidating choice. Most designers use open source software or code on a regular basis wordpress, drupal and many. Gomulkiewicz, how copyleft uses license rights to succeed in the open source software revolution and the implications for article 2b, 36 hous. Aug 15, 2015 the eclipse public license epl is an open source software license used by eclipse foundation for its software. If you intend to prevent companies from selling software linking to your library, you need a nonopen source license. Or is it about time you dip your toes into the uncharted waters of open source. If you intend to prevent companies from selling software linking to your library, you need a non open source license.
Possible duplicate of this question, but i find answers given here more interesting. The selfenforcing nature of open source and free software licenses. Licensing is a major part of what open source and free software are all about, but its still one of the most complicated areas of law. Some common issues in open source licensing open tech. Examples include the gnu allpermissive license, mit license, bsd licenses, apple public source license and apache license. When we compare likeforlike, we discover open source software has no such issues. Open source software oss history is traced to initial efforts in 1971 at massachusetts institute of. Open source licenses grant permission for anybody to use, modify, and share licensed software for any purpose, subject to conditions preserving the provenance and openness of the software. An open source license is a type of license for computer software and other products that allows the source code, blueprint or design to be used, modified andor shared under defined terms and conditions. Effortlessly track and comply with your open source licenses. You can integrate these codes into your client program by. A good example of oss is drupal in all its forms, including drupal mobile.
Sometimes, though, choosing proprietary software makes better business. Endusers do not need to have a license management server, do not need to hold audits, do not need to fear. Oh, just for reference on the whats actually okay with universities might not be what you. Multilicensing is the practice of distributing software under two or more different sets of terms. A permissive software license, sometimes also called bsdlike or bsdstyle license, is a freesoftware license with minimal requirements about how the software can be redistributed. There are a number of different oss licences that are used by the open source community when making software available, and their terms vary considerably. James gatto is a partner at sheppard mullin and is the leader of its open source team. If you want to find out more about any of these topics, were the people to ask. Freeopen source software is everywhere, and software licensing is what enables it. Open source licences can be a source of some confusion.
Lawsuit threatens to break new ground on the gpl and. However, this does not mean that it does not have any legal issues. Open source and third party license notice this notice is provided with respect to the following components which may be included with the product. Dec 11, 2012 open source software refers to any software subjected to a license that makes the source code available to everyone. Open source software is available for virtually any application you could think of. This question is often framed as a war between open source evangelists and commercial. Opensource software is available for virtually any application you could think of. Aug 01, 2008 what are the liability issues involved with using free and open source software foss. Software development using open source and free software licenses. As open source software tends to accommodate the needs of developers rather than the majority of layperson users, the convenience and practicality of open source is frequently criticised.
Jul 31, 2012 the use of open source software oss by businesses in their software applications is becoming increasingly common, learn why it is essential to check the specific terms of any oss licence. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source software. This document gives an overview of some common issues in open source licensing and license. This detailed guide gives you an effective open source licenses comparison. The following licenses are sorted by the number of conditions, from most gnu agplv3 to none unlicense. Every open source component, as well as any component on which it may depend, has a license which you must comply with its own terms and conditions. When versata software sued ameriprise financial services for breaching its software license, it unwittingly unearthed a gpl violation of its own and touched off another lawsuit that could prove to be a leading case on free and open source software licensing. License4j provides software licensing solutions for applications developed with java.
Mar 24, 2010 many developers and designers want to release their work into the world as open source projects. As of 2016, the most popular freesoftware license is the permissive mit license. Understanding open source and free software licensing. We provide the source code of the gpl programs until five 5 years after the discontinuation of same model of this projector product. Apache is open source web server software used on over half of the web servers on the internet. Businesses and savvy developers wont touch a project without this protection. Open source software oss licensing allows organizations to open up their projects to the public for submissions, contributions, modifications, repair, or to build on top of the existing software. Tldrlegal software licenses explained in plain english. Community enforcement of open source and free software licenses 158 compatible and incompatible licensing. Licensing licenses for oss come in different forms, and they all offer different terms of usage. It is designed to be easy to use and integrate in your application. License compliance is a major and costly issue for proprietary software, but the license involved in that case is an end user license agreement eula, not a source license delivering extensive liberties.
Gpl licensed software, in exchange for keeping downstream uses open, prevents developers from releasing their own derivative programs under more restrictive licenses. This is a comparison of free and open source software licenses. Open source licences give you free access to the source code of an application, and the ability to edit, modify and share this code without seeking special. The open source community is vibrant because of this. Aug 20, 2014 download open license server for free. Most designers use opensource software or code on a regular basis wordpress, drupal and many. Prior to 2004, the eclipse community used the common public license cpl as the open source license for most of the open source software made available by. Common open source license obligations source auditor. The ways in which all open source1 licenses are the same are greater than the ways in which they differ but their differences can still be significant. License compliance is not a problem for open source users. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open. For instance, i have some software code under the gnu gpl v2 license on github.